Cinderella, Snow White, and the “Happily Ever After.” Lately, I’ve noticed a growing hostility toward these classic endings. The arguments usually fall into two camps: they are overused, or they are unrealistic. While both points have merit, I don’t think we should disdain the happy ending any more than we should disdain the cold porridge in The Three Bears.
The 1995 Script vs. The Modern Gritty Shell
We all know the “1995 RomCom” formula: Boy meets Girl, they endure a series of happenstance meetings, sparks fly like the Grinch’s heart growing in Whoville, and despite current partners (who are invariably “jerks”), they find “true love” and fade to black.
It is overused. But the modern reaction has been to swing the pendulum toward nihilism—portraying relationships as an “underbelly” of mutual brokenness where the best you can hope for is to find someone just as screwed up as you are.
There is good storytelling in realism, whether it’s the lighthearted banter of When Harry Met Sally or the hopeful grit of Silver Linings Playbook. These movies “zoom in” to magnify a small aspect of how life is. But a problem arises when we try to smash the Fairy Tale into that same realistic mold.
Cutting Off the Heel: The Danger of Literalism
When we read Cinderella as a simple “love story,” we are trying to shove a size 13 foot into a size 10 shoe. In the original Grimm Brothers’ version, the stepmother literally hands her daughters a knife:
“Cut off your toe… Cut a piece off your heel. When you are queen you will no longer have to go on foot.”
When we expect fairy tale endings to be literal blueprints for real-life romance, we end up “mutilating” the story. We miss the point entirely. To read Cinderella only as a romance is to miss the cosmic themes of justice, humility, and the vindication of the oppressed.
The Pull-Back Lens
Where a romantic drama “zooms in” on the mundane, the fairy tale “pulls far back” to give us a glimpse of what life might be. It offers a transcendent picture of a different world—a world where the heavy wooden shoe is finally traded for the golden slipper that fits perfectly.
Instead of trying to emulate the literal actions of fairy tale characters, we should imitate the morals and values they represent. The “Happily Ever After” isn’t a promise of a life without conflict; it is a symbolic reminder that there is a “Higher Law” where truth is recognized and the “true bride” is finally found.
When Cinderella puts her foot into the slipper and it fits perfectly, it isn’t just about a wedding; it is about the world finally being “put right.”
Leave a Reply